Nagamaki (長巻) - A unique Japanese sword
Nagamaki (長巻) - A unique Japanese sword
One of the few artistic representation of the Nagamaki; on the centre left, a fleeing warrior is holding said weapon while running from a cavalry charge. From the Kiyomizu Dera Engi Emaki (清水寺縁起絵巻)
The Nagamaki (長巻) is a unique sword design found only in Japan, with very few exceptions.
The name itself means "long wrapping" and there is a very specific reason behind it that I'm going to explain in this article.
Before discussing the weapon itself, it should be clarified why it is considered a sword; despite having the length required to be classified in the polearms category, the nagamaki is used as a sword, which means that both hands are in a fixed position and the weapon is held in the same way a sword is held, with few-to-none hands changing along the handle.
The closest example of this weapon found outside Japan is the European Spetum, although this weapon was used as a polearm rather than as a sword.
History
It is very hard to pinpoint with accuracy when this weapon appeared on the Japanese battlefield, mainly because it's often confused with the naginata (薙刀); however, the main theory is that the nagamaki was introduced in the late Kamakura period, around the early 14th century.
In this period, extremely long sword called Nodachi (野太刀) started to be used by Japanese warriors both on foot as well on horseback.
Before discussing the weapon itself, it should be clarified why it is considered a sword; despite having the length required to be classified in the polearms category, the nagamaki is used as a sword, which means that both hands are in a fixed position and the weapon is held in the same way a sword is held, with few-to-none hands changing along the handle.
The closest example of this weapon found outside Japan is the European Spetum, although this weapon was used as a polearm rather than as a sword.
History
It is very hard to pinpoint with accuracy when this weapon appeared on the Japanese battlefield, mainly because it's often confused with the naginata (薙刀); however, the main theory is that the nagamaki was introduced in the late Kamakura period, around the early 14th century.
In this period, extremely long sword called Nodachi (野太刀) started to be used by Japanese warriors both on foot as well on horseback.
Because such weapons, with their short hilts relative to their blade lengths, were difficult to handle, it became common practice to wrap the lower part of the blade with thin cord, effectively extending the grip and making the weapon easier to swing and control.
These nodachi were called Nakamaki Nodachi (中巻野太刀) which means central wrapped field sword or simply Nakamaki (中巻- central wrapping).
These nodachi were called Nakamaki Nodachi (中巻野太刀) which means central wrapped field sword or simply Nakamaki (中巻- central wrapping).
Later, the hilt itself was simply made longer, to produce the nagamaki, which consisted of a sword-like blade about a meter in length, mounted in an equally long hilt that was usually wrapped in leather or silk cord, like the hilt of an ordinary tachi or uchi-gatana.
A very approximate sketch made by me explaining the pattern that lead to the creation of the nagamaki. On top, a nodachi, in the middle a nakamaki nodachi and at the bottom a nagamaki.
The nagamaki was still used in the 15th and 16th century, although the shift from the warfare of the early 14th century to the one of the late 15th century, where mass formations started to prevail, made this weapon rather ineffective in such contexts: due to its size and intended use, the space required wasn't compatible with the pikes formations and tactics.
Despite this limit, it was still popular during the Sengoku period among some clan, like the Oda and the Uesugi, which often deployed soldiers with this weapon.
However, due to the decreasing popularity of this weapon in the 16th century, many nagamaki were cut down and refurbished as swords and short swords; this process is called nagamaki naoshi (長巻直し) and it was also done with naginata and nodachi.
Due to the beauty and effectiveness of this design, many swords were directly made as if they were cut down nagamaki or naginata; so they aren't nagamaki naoshi in the strict meaning.
A Nagamaki naoshi; picture taken from here
This trend of shortening nagamaki continued in the Edo period, were laws concerning the sword's length were promoted by the Shogunate.
A Nagamaki naoshi; picture taken from here
This trend of shortening nagamaki continued in the Edo period, were laws concerning the sword's length were promoted by the Shogunate.
Shape and Use
The most specific feature of the nagamaki is that the handle is as long (or slightly shorter/longer) than the blade, which was usually designed as Japanese swords, especially Nodachi (野太刀), are: slightly curved with a single edge and (usually) a shobu zukuri blade geometry or at least a very slender and narrow Ōkissaki, with a very long tang.
Four different examples of antique nagamaki blades.
The blade is usually in between 70 and 100 cm (although some exceptions existed) and was thicker and more heavy than most Japanese blade, since it was meant for the battlefield.
Sometimes the blade was very similar to the ones that can be found in some variations of the Ōnaginata (大薙刀).
Sometimes the blade was very similar to the ones that can be found in some variations of the Ōnaginata (大薙刀).
Another important aspect is that the handle is made like the handle of a Japanese sword, which means that is wrapped in silk, leather cords or a mix of the two, and could be either curved or straight.
It was usually fitted with a small tsuba (鍔) or with a type of crossguard called hadome which is often used in Japanese polearms to work as parrying hooks.
It was usually fitted with a small tsuba (鍔) or with a type of crossguard called hadome which is often used in Japanese polearms to work as parrying hooks.
Two possible variations of the same weapon made by me; the one on the top has a curved handle, with two different types of wrapping, a small tsuba and a very long, curved and slender shobu zukuri blade, similar to the blades used for some type of naginata.
The one below has a straight red handle, with a hadome guard and a minimal curved shinogi zukuri blade with a Chukissaki, which is more similar to a normal sword blade.
The one below has a straight red handle, with a hadome guard and a minimal curved shinogi zukuri blade with a Chukissaki, which is more similar to a normal sword blade.
It was primarily intended to be used on foot, although just like the naginata and the nodachi, it could be used on horseback as well.
It was used to unseat horseman as well as cutting the horse itself, and being a top heavy polearm, the cut was extremely powerful and capable of damaging the bones underneath the area protected with light armor.
Since the blade was usually narrow and slender, it was also used to poke into the unarmored zone of the enemy.
On the right, two Nagamaki blades with a straight handle; from 武器袖鏡. 初編
Differences between Nagamaki and Naginata
Although these two weapons are closely associated, there are some key differences that are worth mentioning.
First of all, the mounting; the naginata has a longer straight and lacquered handle, and usually it has a shorter blade, even if there are some exceptions. While the nagamaki has longer blade, an equally long handle wrapped in cords or leather which could be curved as well.
However, there are some very subtle differences even in the blade: the naginata has more blade variations, which could be much more curved, occasionally with a sharpened false edge, it lacks the typical yokote, which is the line that delimited the kissaki or tip of the blade and has on the other hand a unique groove that is called naginata-hi (薙刀樋 ).
The nagamaki could have a yokote, is usually longer, has a less pronounced curvature and lacks the naginata-hi.
On the right, a very curved and short naginata blade with a red groove; on the left, a longer nagamaki blade with a very small curvature and a shinogi zukuri blade geometry with a chukissaki; this is how far the two respective weapons could get.
I hope that you have enjoyed this article! For any question please feel free to ask in the comment.
Gunbai.
There appears to be a weapon called "swordstaff" that was used in Scandinavia, which supposedly looks like a sword (crossguard and all) mounted on a pole. It's still a polearm though.
ReplyDeleteEuropean ahlspiess does have a blade to shaft ratio close to 1:1 like nagamaki, although it is basically a very long iron spike mounted on a pole.
Yes there are some weapons which resemble the nagamaki as far as blade to shaft ratio is concerned, but is the design + use that makes this weapon unique.
DeleteThe closest equivalent (I believe) is a greatsword with a leather covered ricasso, which is after all where the idea of the nagamaki came from.
Hey just wondering could you perhaps show me some more variations of this weapon.
ReplyDeleteAlso well I was looking for different Yari types I came across this weapon it looks like a mace but who knows could be a plunger( I'm joking obviously) I can't read it,so I figure to show it to you, the name is practice on the top left corner.
http://www.kaneka-med.jp/products/intervention/ip_020/img/pct_02.gif
Hello Kevin!
DeleteYes sure, here there are more pictures:
https://i.pinimg.com/originals/50/3a/03/503a03396aa284cea683f373381b0659.jpg
http://winners-auction.jp/productImage/14044
https://scontent-ort2-1.cdninstagram.com/vp/63d5dccc70652f16652c4b8618459da0/5C1BE8CB/t51.2885-15/e35/39687813_302706570308928_922171676504883200_n.jpg
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DU3tQtbVAAIUAVm.jpg
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DUCfiJRU0AIt8FT.jpg
http://www.zest.name/img/sword/zs902_oonagamaki_toushin.jpg
http://www.zest.name/img/sword/zs902_oonagamaki.jpg
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DVB1LhNVMAEyLpZ.jpg
http://busou2.sakura.ne.jp/t20081030f.JPG
Regarding the "weapon" you linked... Well I have to say that I'm quite curious on how you end up there while looking for yari, but that's actually a scheme of a catheter ( in fact, you can read it at the bottom: カテーテル有効長 means "catheter effective length" ;) ). Internet is crazy sometime!!
Thanks, well now I feel embarrassed didn't even know what a catheter was learn something new everyday I guess.
DeleteBy the way I'll probably email you a little bit later there's some things I like to discuss with you.
Is really difficult to find information on the nagamaki,in my opinion the most overlooked of the Nihonto, if i were to chose a japanese main weapon i would use one of these( or a goedendag-like kanabo,but that is for another time)
ReplyDeleteI am really interested in the practical usage of such weapon . I really appreciate the versatility of it being both a sword and a polearm,yes in your article you specified how it is a sword , but that is in the school of thought that don t considers large two handed sword and such as polearms,at least from an ideological point of view
One curious thing i have noticed is how correspondant weapons to the nagamaki seems to appear in other asian cultures,rather than european ones
Example of this category of weapons are the single specimen zhanma jian,the pudao,the Yue Fei dao,many two handed dha and arguably the panabas. One cannot but wonders the reasons of such preminence for this type of weapons in this area
I hope you found some new information here in this article! I agree, the nagamaki is highly overlooked.
DeleteAlthough I said that it is a sword, since it is used as swords are used, it has the reach and the hitting power of a polearm indeed.
The nagamaki has the capabilities of a nodachi but it is easier to use due to the extra leverage and it is great against horses and lightly armored foes (arguably, the majority of soldiers in any medieval army around the world).
During the early sengoku period, there was this saying: "槍が使えないなら長巻を使え" which means "if you cannot use a spear, use a nagamaki".
You are right about the fact that these types of weapons were much common in Asia and SE Asia compared to Europe (although greatswords were used as well); it might be related to the climate, which is a theory often used to explain the presence of cutting centric swords in those places. The very hot and humid weather didn't allow the common soldiers to wear heavy clothes to protect themselves from cutting so you have these very specialized cutting polearms.
It's not a perfect theory but I think it's a good point to begin with
Which weapon was more common during the Sengoku period, the Nodachi or the Nagamaki?
ReplyDeleteProbably the nagamaki, because after all it was an "easier to use nodachi". However both weapon gradually disappeared from the battlefield of the 16th century in favour of the Yari polearms
DeleteButterfly Knives for Sale - Buy Quality Blades at Discount Prices Online - A balisong, also known as a fan knife, butterfly knives or Batangas knife, is a folding pocketknife. Its distinct features are two handles counter-rotating around the tang such
ReplyDeletereal swords for sale are even available nowadays even though they were used by people so many years ago. Swords were the primary weapons of the people of historical era and they used to carry with them almost everywhere.
ReplyDeleteI really liked your article, there's no much information about the Nagamaki out there (at least not in English). But I have one question: Where did you get the information that the Nagamaki was used in conjunction with a hadome? Your article was the only info I could find about this detail. Do you have any sources stating the use of hadome on the Nagamaki (or even pictures of hadome on Nagamaki).
ReplyDeleteThank you so much! I know there is very little info on this weapon.
DeleteBy the way here there is an example of a Nagamaki with hadome:
https://i.pinimg.com/236x/be/67/e0/be67e05b2426769a24895d8410413eed--iaido-kampf.jpg
Essentialy any Japanese polearms could sport hadome handguards.
Hi,
ReplyDeleteAwesome article, as always! :)
May I ask, is there any info about how nagamaki were carried when sheeted?
Thank you!
DeleteI don't have directed information but we can infer on how naginata and nodachi were carried. They were most likely carried by a servant by hands, while resting on the shoulder. Most likely it wasn't carried on the back like they did with some nodachi.
Whoah the hadome on that nagamaki extend from the flats, not the edge!
DeleteAs far as I know, nodachi and naginata have tsuba, while yari and nagamaki sometimes have hadome... so could the nagamaki be more thrust oriented like a yari?
Yes that's true! It's a little bit odd although it wasn't uncommon to have crossguard in the classic position.
DeleteHadome hooks can be presents on naginata as well, and more so some of this crossguard incorporate discguard as well so the line is very blurry if you will:
http://www.tokensugita.com/Yari01.jpg
I wouldn't say that a nagamaki is more thrust oriented like a yari given the fact that it has a curved blade, but you can definitely use similar techniques
Hi!
ReplyDeleteI've read in quite a few places that the nagamaki was intended to be used against cavalry, but the same thing used to be wrongly said about nodachi swords. Is there any reliable reference on this intended use?
Thanks! Your blog is phenomenal!
Thank you for your words!
DeleteWell it kinda makes sense to claim such a thing since the nagamaki was developed after the nodachi in the sense that the latter is a variation of the former with a longer hilt.
However, afaik there are no mentions of such specialized usage for such weapons.
They can be used to chop horse legs or to poke the rider, but not if the horsemen is charging as it would be a rather dangerous tactic if you ask me. The best way to stop cavalry are organized dense formations, and once the horsemen is unable to maneuver, long edged weapons might be useful to dismount him or harm the poor horse compared to normal spears, for example.
However the idea that those weapons were used against charging horsemens is quite off in my opinion and they don't have any specific references in historical sources in Japan.
As far as we know, both were used as polearms in between staff weapons and swords.
So GreatMing blog has some examples of 1500's "based on Japanese katana" Ming swords that have an extended metal collar (habaki) seemingly for grip: https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-YETubk6RRO4/WNtm2VttFaI/AAAAAAAADgE/Tf39oExhV6MH7lJZZBAalzkuOKcI9h2igCLcB/s640/changdao_dandao.jpg
ReplyDeleteAre there Japanese swords with extended habaki like that? I've also seen photos of Korean swords with a metal collar long enough to grip like a nagamaki
That's quite new to me! As far as I know, there are no such long habaki found on Japanese swords. I haven't seen all of them of course but if anything that would be extremely rare. To grip longsword like nagamaki, a longer wrapped cord was applied directly to the blade, after the tsuba ( this is also ironically the origin of the nagamaki itself).
Deletevery interesting ! TY all
ReplyDeleteI have read that the Nagamaki is also the iconic weapon of the onna-bugeisha,
a type of female warrior belonging to the Japanese upper class.
also it was common to have at the home for protection when the men were not home !
Thanks! But actually what you are referring to is the Naginata, which was associated with female warriors during the late Edo and early Meji period.
DeleteThe Nagamaki served as the inspiration of the Elve swords scene in Lord of the Rings movies
ReplyDeletehttps://images.sellbrite.com/production/19698/45_UC1373/a25565c0-5bf3-51e8-9374-1473c34f08aa.jpg
I been considering getting a Nagamaki from Samurai Swords someday. I like how potentially versatile it can be. Want more range? Just have your right hand near the center and your left hand near the pommel. Want more control? Just have your right hand near the guard and your left hand near the center.
ReplyDeleteThe Nagamaki served as the inspiration of the Elve swords scene in Lord of the Rings movies
ReplyDeleteFrom the TvTropes page on "BFS", Real Life:
ReplyDeleteThe ōdachi or "great sword" (also known as a nodachi or "field sword") is most easily described as a larger version of the katana or tachi, and was intended to be used by foot soldiers against cavalry. Typical examples were over five feet long, which is longer than the typical Japanese man is tall◊. However, it's speculated that many or perhaps even most ōdachi were never used in combat. Forging one was proof of a swordsmith's skill, and owning one was a status symbol for a samurai wealthy enough to afford it. However, polearms (such as the naginata) were cheaper to build, easier to train people with, and all-around more useful in the hands of a skilled soldier. There are also styles of using the nodachi in a very aggressive manner to defeat polearms, by essentially advancing toward a foe with polearm and using multiple rapid downward cuts to batter the enemy weapon down and cut the head and shoulders with the sheer weight and momentum of the blade, or as a weapon from horseback.
Judging by what you said about the nodachi and the katana in other pages, I'm skeptical about the fact the speculation that they weren't used at all, so I trusted your judgment on this one: I wat thinking of editing it, but I wanted to make sure I didn't write worse stuff by mistake.
They seem exceptionally similar to Thracian rhomphaia.
ReplyDelete